Talk:Why are you trying to tear down other people's faith?

From Iron Chariots Wiki
Revision as of 00:47, 11 November 2010 by BunniRabbi (Talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search

"...motives an atheist may have for arguing against gods and religion."

This seems inappropriate. An atheist need not be anti-religious, and this assumes that the atheist in question is.

"an atheist does not consider religious faith a benefit. In fact, it is the cornerstone of dogmatism"

Similar problem. Religious atheists obviously do consider faith a benefit. Religious faith, likewise, does not need to lead to dogmatism. To be fair, the use of faith to advocate dogmatism is nearly synonymous with religious practice, but is is erroneous to apply this to all religions.

"...people losing their faith in superstition is seen as a Good Thing. "

It is likewise problematic to use 'faith in superstition' as a synonym for religious faith. Superstition asserts both the unprovable and the dis-proven. The religion of many people can be described this way, but religious views which assert unprovable views are not inherently antagonistic to reason and generally not antagonistic to atheism. Believing "humans has moral value" is an unprovable assertion, but is not antagonistic in either fashion.

Personal tools
wiki navigation