Shut up, that's why

From Iron Chariots Wiki
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(update link to Greta's blog)
(Rhetorical tactics)
 
Line 5: Line 5:
 
Christina identifies several tactics that fall into this category:
 
Christina identifies several tactics that fall into this category:
  
* Why talk about about [[atheism]] when there are much bigger problems in the world?
+
* Why talk about [[atheism]] when there are much bigger problems in the world?
 
* Religion is not in the same category as science and politics, and should not be expected to prove itself the same way (aka [[non-overlapping magisteria]]).
 
* Religion is not in the same category as science and politics, and should not be expected to prove itself the same way (aka [[non-overlapping magisteria]]).
 
* Why do you care what other people believe?
 
* Why do you care what other people believe?

Latest revision as of 04:55, 9 October 2011

"Shut up, that's why" is the name given by author and blogger Greta Christina to a category of rhetorical tactics aimed not at countering atheists' arguments, but at stopping argument altogether. While some of them are logical fallacies, others are not even structured well enough to qualify as logical fallacies.

Rhetorical tactics

Christina identifies several tactics that fall into this category:

  • Why talk about atheism when there are much bigger problems in the world?
  • Religion is not in the same category as science and politics, and should not be expected to prove itself the same way (aka non-overlapping magisteria).
  • Why do you care what other people believe?
  • Religion is private. Why do we need to talk about this?
  • Atheists act as though they're superior to everyone else.
  • Atheists are whiny.
  • I'm tired of hearing about atheism. Can't you give it a rest?
  • Can't we just agree to disagree?

External link

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox