Roman Catholicism

From Iron Chariots Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
For more information, see the Wikipedia article:
The Catholic Church is lead by the Pope who resides in the Vatican, a city state inside Rome. St Peter's Basilica is the church building most associated with the Pope, although it is not a cathedral.
View from behind St Peter's Basilica to the square in front of the church. Tens of thousands often gather to hear the Pope speak.

Roman Catholicism is part of the Catholic Church that follows the western rites or traditions. Together with the Eastern Catholic Churches, it forms one of the three major branches of Christianity, along with Protestantism and Orthodox Christianity. The Catholic Church is the largest denomination in Christianity. Its head is the Pope. The church has a long history and its position has evolved on many issues over the centuries.



Christianity grew out the churches established by missionaries, such as Paul, in the countries surrounding the Mediterranean Sea. During this time, much of the Mediterranean region was under Roman control. The Roman empire split into a Western and Byzantine empires in 395 CE. This political separation allowed Christianity to develop along separate lines, with different traditions and liturgy. The Western empire collapsed in 476 CE although the papacy continued in Rome. The relationship between the western Latin and eastern Greek churches gradually declined, particularly when the Franks gained sufficient influence with the papacy to cause their king to be crowned Holy Roman Emperor in 800 CE. This action was taken as a snub to the Eastern emperor and the Byzantine empire. Political and theological differences finally resulted in the East-West or Great Schism which separated the empires and churches in 1054 CE. The Western church, lead by the Pope in Rome, became the Catholic Church, generally located in western Europe. The Eastern church became known as the Orthodox Church and was generally located in the Eastern Mediterranean.

Christianity Branches.png

The official sacred text is the Latin Vulgate translation of the Bible. The church maintains lists of approved translations, which usually differ from Protestant versions. Throughout the Middle Ages, the Bible was only available in the Latin Vulgate translation in the Western church. [1] However, most lay Christians were illiterate or could not read Latin. In 1199, the Catholic Church banned any further unauthorised translations of the Bible.

"[...] the Catholic Church resisted the idea of bible translations, not only into modern languages currently, but even when the Latin Vulgate was written about 1000 years earlier. Catholics wanted their interpretation to be the only interpretation. It wasn't a conspiracy, just a firm belief that their interpretation was the right one. [2]"

The papacy has been based in the Vatican during the early church and on a continual basis since 1378. The Vatican is now a small independent state within Rome. For this reason, the senior leadership of the Catholic Church is sometimes referred to as "the Vatican" or simply "Rome".

In 1517, Martin Luther sent his Ninety-Five Theses to several bishops. In it, he criticised Catholic theology and practices, including the sale of indulgences. He also emphasised personal Bible reading and translations into local languages. This eventually caused a schism in the church and lead to the protestant movement.

The English king Henry VIII was involved in a divorce dispute with the Catholic Church. In 1534, the king declared himself the head of the Church of England, causing a schism with Rome and the king to be excommunicated. The Church of England was later reunited with the Catholic Church in 1555. The Church of England again schismed in 1558 under Elizabeth I.

In 2013, Pope Francis was selected by the cardinals lead the church.

Social policies

The contemporary Catholic Church is characterised by:

Many of these policies are also used by some other denominations. Although contraception is officially banned by the church, this teaching is largely ignored in many cultures.

In a break with the inaction of previous leaders, Francis has spoken on a range of social and environmental issues. Francis criticised the senior leaders of the Catholic church as being narcissistic, hardened, excessively active, uncoordinated, non-spiritual, boastful bureaucrats. [3]

Dogma and practices

While most Christian apologetics are common to Catholicism, there are some doctrines, practices and related apologetics that are strongly emphasised or uniquely Catholic:

"I declare that the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church's faithful."

— Pope John Paul II, 1994[4]

More Catholic doctrine



The Crusades were a series of military expeditions sent by various European kingdoms during the Middle Ages. They were directly initiated or sanctioned by the Catholic Church. They aimed to recapture Jerusalem from Islamic states, persecute heretics and Jews, and gain converts by force.


Initiated in 1250s, the Inquisition refers to various institutions in the Catholic church to promote orthodoxy and persecute heretics, potential apostates and Jews. During the Late Middle Ages and early Renaissance, these institutions were active in many questionable activities including torture to gain forced confessions (although less than other tribunals of the time), execution of thousands of people by burning people alive, confiscation of property, forced exile, imprisonment, anonymous denunciation and censorship. The last execution by the Inquisition was in 1826.

Historic opposition to science

Historically, the church has opposed scientific discoveries that were considered threatening to its theology. In 1633, the Inquisition tried and condemned Galileo Galilei over his astronomical observations that supported the heliocentric theory.

In recent times, the church has become more accepting of science. It reversed its position regarding Galileo in 1992 and has since praised Galileo's discoveries. The current view of the church is that science and faith cannot be in conflict:

"methodical research in all branches of knowledge, provided it is carried out in a truly scientific manner and does not override moral laws, can never conflict with the faith, because the things of the world and the things of faith derive from the same God [9]"

The Catholic Church generally (and unofficially) accepts both evolution and creationism but rejects young Earth creationism. Some Catholic organisations argue against evolution. Incidentally, Gregor Mendel was a Catholic friar and the founder of genetics.

Historic sale of indulgences

Indulgences are a remission of temporal punishment for venal sins that have already been confessed. They are granted by the clergy for various works, such building churches visiting shrines, charity or pious conduct. The specific actions that qualify have been revised from time to time. During the Middle Ages, indulgences were available for monetary payment and became extremely popular. They were used to fund large building projects, such as cathedrals, hospitals, schools and to pay for costly appointments. Many indulgences were sold that were contrary to official church doctrine; accusations were made against Johann Tetzel that he told an indulgence for full forgiveness for all future sins. The sale of indulgences were a means of defrauding credulous believers and gaining immense wealth for the church. Apologists argue that the sale of indulgences was never official church policy. [10] However, Pope Leo X himself gave indulgences for payment. In the contemporary church, payments are no longer an acceptable means of gaining indulgences.


Although technically banned, the buying and selling of religious offices became widespread in the 9th and 10th centuries. This is referred to as simony. The practice reduced after reforms were introduced. These positions were often funded by the sale of indulgences or relics.


Christians have persecuted Jews since the early church. Many of first writers within the early Christian organisations that became the Catholic church were explicitly anti-Semitic (e.g. St. Augustine). It took until 1965 for the Catholic church to declare that contemporary Jews were not to he held responsible for the death of Jesus. [11]

Opposition to contraception

The Catholic Church has a long standing policy against the use of contraception (except the unreliable NFP method), even when it may prevent the spread of disease. This includes undermining efforts to encourage the use of condoms by spreading misinformation. [12] However, there is some evidence that HIV infection is not prevented by promoting the use of contraception, partly because people using contraception may perform riskier sexual acts. [13] The correct use of condoms is effective at greatly reducing the risk of infection by a variety of STDs. [14] The church's stance is a form of religiously motivated medical neglect.

The church's view stands in contrast to almost all other Christian denominations.

Opposition to abortion

For more information, see the Wikipedia article:

The church has been opposed all direct abortions and claims their position is unchangeable. Procuring or performing an abortion leads to an automatic excommunication. This includes:

  • no abortions for women who are too unwell to carry the pregnancy to term, unless the treatment for the mother indirectly causes the abortion.[15]
  • no abortions for rape or incest victims [16]
  • no abortions even if the baby would be severely deformed.[16]

It does allow termination of ectopic pregnancies or the uterus is itself cancerous. The church's stance is a form of religiously motivated medical neglect.

Lack of open opposition to the Nazi party

Pope Pius XII was the leader of the Catholic church before and during world war 2. He is sometimes accused by writers, such as John Cornwell, of not doing enough to publicly oppose the Nazi regime. His defenders point out that he spoke out against war but was limited in what he could achieve, given that Italy was allied with the Nazi government. Pius XII provided discrete assistance to Jews, resistance fighters and allied forces.

"[Pius XII] had so little scope of action that it is impossible to judge the motives for his silence during the war, while Rome was under the heel of Mussolini and later occupied by Germany. ... But even if his prevarications and silences were performed with the best of intentions, he had an obligation in the postwar period to explain those actions"

— John Cornwell

The pope's actions compares poorly to (exceptional and rare) Christians such as Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who opposed the Nazis on moral grounds and was executed as a result. Partly due to the secrecy of the Vatican, the exact events surrounding Pius XII are still secret and remain controversial to this day.

Misuse of funds

There has been many instances of questionable use of funds, a general lack of transparency on how money is allocated and unwillingness to be audited by a 3rd party [17]

Child sex abuse

Since around 2000, the world media has been reporting on widespread child sexual abuse committed by priests. The abuse mostly occurred between 1950 and 1980. At the time of abuse, the age of the victims was typically between 11 and 14 [18] but was as low as 3 years old. The Catholic church, being the largest denomination in Christianity, is the church of a significant proportion of abusers. The Catholic church's response to abusive priests was often to cover up the abuse, using a "code of silence" and transferring the priests into new areas where they sometimes continued to abuse children. Information concerning criminal acts was not passed to the police. The U.N. Committee on the Rights of the Child said: [19]

"[The Vatican] has not acknowledged the extent of the crimes committed, has not taken the necessary measures to address cases of child sexual abuse and to protect children, and has adopted policies and practices which have led to the continuation of the abuse by, and the impunity of, the perpetrators"

Current attitude to atheists and apostasy

The Catholic Church regards secularism as a threat:

"it is imperative that the entire Catholic community in the United States come to realize the grave threats to the Church’s public moral witness presented by a radical secularism which finds increasing expression in the political and cultural spheres."

— Benedict XVI [20]

Some Catholic leaders claim that atheists are not fully human. [21]

"Man is by nature and vocation a religious being. Coming from God, going toward God, man lives a fully human life only if he freely lives by his bond with God. [22]"

"There is something not totally human if you leave out transcendent [God] and you [atheists] are not fully human. They have an impoverished understanding to what it is to be human. We are all made by God."

— Cardinal Cormac Murphy O’Connor [21]

Leaving the church

Since the church does not impose any material punishment for leaving the church, the main adverse consequence is the potential disapproval from family and society. The penalty of apostasy in the Catholic Church is automatic excommunication. [23] Excommunication is said to be Latae sententiae because the sentence is automatically imposed, if the apostasy is a wilful act carried out by an informed person. [24] An excommunicated person is forbidden to receive the sacraments (communion, weddings, etc) but is still allowed to attend church events. [24]

Between 2006 and 2009, act of actus formalis defectionis ab Ecclesia catholica was a way to inform the church of defection. It is unclear if this is required for an apostasy to be considered "formal", rather than "material". This act required notification of a competent ecclesiastical authority. [25] After 2009, changes to canon law abolished this procedure and inquiries to find an replacement have not been answered. [26]


The church never changes its teachings

"Of course no teachings have been changed. I expect nothing less of the media to completely misunderstand everything, but the rest of us would have to be complete idiots to think the Church has changed its teachings. Catholicism is a religion of absolutes: it doesn’t change with the whims of the culture, or hide under the banner of “progressivism.” Think about it, Catholics believe the Church is the fullness of truth. 2000 years ago morality was the same as it is today, and the same as it will be 2000 years from now.[27]"

The church as changes its position on a number of issues including the use of torture, owning slaves, the suppression of heretics and other religions by force[28], geocentrism, the importance of marriage, the acceptability of sexual pleasure, lending money at interest, etc.

See also


  1. [1]
  2. Darren Roberts, Where Did We Get A Bible?, 2012
  3. [2]
  4. [3]
  5. [4]
  6. [5]
  7. [6]
  8. [7]
  9. [8]
  10. [9]
  11. [10]
  12. [11]
  13. [12]
  14. [13]
  15. [14]
  16. 16.0 16.1 [15]
  17. [16]
  18. A Report on the Crisis in the Catholic Church in the United States (John Jay Report), 2004
  19. [17]
  20. Address Of His Holiness Benedict XVI To The Bishops Of The United States Of America On Their "AD Limina" Visit, Thursday, 19 January 2012
  21. 21.0 21.1 [18]
  22. [19]
  23. Code of Canon Law, Book 4, Part 2, Title 1, 1364 [20]
  24. 24.0 24.1 Colin B. Donovan, "Heresy, Schism and Apostasy" [21]
  25. Actus Formalis Defectionis Ab Ecclesia Catholica, 13 March 2006
  26. Church Continues to Block Formal Cessation of Membership, 20/07/2011 [22]
  27. [23]
  28. [24]

External links

v · d Religion
v · d Abrahamic religions
Abrahamic Religions   Baha'i · Christianity · Christian Science · Druze · Islam · Jehovah's Witnesses · Judaism · Mandaeism · Mormonism · Samaritanism · Rastafarianism

v · d Dharmic religions
Dharmic Religions   Buddhism · Hinduism · Jainism · Sikhism · Zoroastrianism

v · d Folk religions
African folk religions   African traditional religion · Santeria · Egyptian mythology
North American folk religions   Inuit mythology

v · d New religious movements
    Mormonism · Jehovah's Witnesses · Scientology

v · d Taoic religions
Taoic religions   Shinto · Taoism · Confucianism · Caodaism · Chondogyo · Chen Tao · Jeung San Do · Yiguandao
Personal tools
wiki navigation