Religion provides hope

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(Religion also provides despair: Reworded some things fixing a few typos.)
(Religion also provides fear)
(6 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 6: Line 6:
  
 
===Is this desirable?===
 
===Is this desirable?===
This argument is comparable to the statement, "It would be cruel to take away someone's antidepressants, since that person would succumb to depression". This may be true in some (perhaps even many) cases, but in general it is better to raise people not to require drugs to be happy. Similarly, it is better to be able to find hope and meaning without having to resort to religion.
+
This argument is comparable to the statement, "It would be cruel to take away a coke addict's supply, since that person would succumb to withdrawal pains". While this action would likely cause temporary pain to the addict, in the long run, the former addict would benefit greatly from eliminating his dependence. Similarly, it is better to be able to find hope and meaning without having to resort to religion.
  
===Religion also provides despair===
+
===Religion also provides fear===
This argument also ignores the fact that for many people, religion brings unhappiness: in many forms of religion, people are told that having sexual thoughts is a [[sin]]; homosexuals are told that they are vile and wicked; and some denominations preach that all humans, no matter how much good they do, are miserable sinners who deserve to be tortured for all eternity.
+
This argument also ignores the fact that for many people, religion brings unhappiness, guilt is one example.  In many forms of religion, people are told that having sexual thoughts is a [[sin]] and for younger people with average sex drives avoiding sexual thoughts is likely to be difficult or impossible.  A wide range of sexual actions, even feelings outside marriage or even within marriage are considered sinful, further homosexuals are told that they are vile and wicked. Some denominations preach that all humans, no matter how much good they do, are miserable sinners who deserve to be tortured for all eternity.
  
 
The hope that such religions provide is not the uplifting hope of improving one's future, but rather the hope of evading just punishment.
 
The hope that such religions provide is not the uplifting hope of improving one's future, but rather the hope of evading just punishment.
  
Many forms of Christianity teach that the majority of mankind will go to [[Hell]].  The fear of this may cause great distress.  If you are on death's door and were raised to believe that you may be going to hell, it can create great stress and energy that could have been spent better possibly saying goodbye to loved ones.  It causes friends and relatives stress to think that perhaps a recent loved one that died could be in hell.  It is difficult to estimate how much stress and unhappiness is caused by the fear of hell and the suffering that one is supposed to have while in hell.  Many people may be reluctant to admit how much they fear that they are sinners and could be destined to go to hell as well as the fear they hold that loved ones were sinners and are in hell.  The fact that hell is forever, its hard to even imagine.  Many may be uncomfortable outside on a hot day or sitting in a boring meeting, yet hell is portrayed far, far worse than these daily annoyances that many may try to avoid.
+
Many forms of Christianity teach that the majority of mankind will go to [[Hell]].  The fear of this may cause great distress.  If you are on death's door and were raised to believe that you may be going to hell, it can create great stress. It can also use up energy that could have been spent better possibly saying goodbye to loved ones or even fighting whatever life-threatening condition is affecting you.  It causes friends and relatives stress to think that perhaps a loved one that died could be in hell.  It is difficult to estimate how much stress and unhappiness is caused by the fear of hell and the suffering that one is supposed to endure while in hell.  Many people may be reluctant to admit how much they fear that they are sinners and could be destined to go to hell as well as the fear they hold that loved ones were sinners and are in hell.  The fact that hell is forever, its hard to even imagine.  Many may be uncomfortable outside on a hot day or sitting in a boring meeting, yet hell is portrayed far, far worse than these daily annoyances that many may try to avoid.
 +
 
 +
Religion also causes fear of supernatural horrors in this life, many people believe that witches, demons, or evil spirits are sabotaging their efforts or plotting to attack them. Normally, one would try to get a person to disbelieve in, or at least forget about, these sorts of paranoid delusions, however, if they are a member of a religion that accepts or even encourages these sorts of beliefs, it may be very difficult to convince someone to let go of them.
 +
 
 +
Religion can ''also'' cause fear of non-believers or believers in different religions, because it demands loyalty to a particular ideology, and that that ideology be defended against all conceivable threats. This fear leads to needless prejudice and sometimes even violence. Even "moderate" religionists are often afraid of the decline of their own [[faith]], even they can't relate this decline to any definite tangible harm to themselves or others.
  
 
==See also==
 
==See also==

Revision as of 12:24, 12 September 2011

One common apologetic is the argument that religion provides hope, or meaning, or the assurance of the love of God, and that taking away a person's religion would be cruel.

Contents

Counter-arguments

Red herring

Whether or not religion provides hope or meaning has nothing to do with whether it is true.

Is this desirable?

This argument is comparable to the statement, "It would be cruel to take away a coke addict's supply, since that person would succumb to withdrawal pains". While this action would likely cause temporary pain to the addict, in the long run, the former addict would benefit greatly from eliminating his dependence. Similarly, it is better to be able to find hope and meaning without having to resort to religion.

Religion also provides fear

This argument also ignores the fact that for many people, religion brings unhappiness, guilt is one example. In many forms of religion, people are told that having sexual thoughts is a sin and for younger people with average sex drives avoiding sexual thoughts is likely to be difficult or impossible. A wide range of sexual actions, even feelings outside marriage or even within marriage are considered sinful, further homosexuals are told that they are vile and wicked. Some denominations preach that all humans, no matter how much good they do, are miserable sinners who deserve to be tortured for all eternity.

The hope that such religions provide is not the uplifting hope of improving one's future, but rather the hope of evading just punishment.

Many forms of Christianity teach that the majority of mankind will go to Hell. The fear of this may cause great distress. If you are on death's door and were raised to believe that you may be going to hell, it can create great stress. It can also use up energy that could have been spent better possibly saying goodbye to loved ones or even fighting whatever life-threatening condition is affecting you. It causes friends and relatives stress to think that perhaps a loved one that died could be in hell. It is difficult to estimate how much stress and unhappiness is caused by the fear of hell and the suffering that one is supposed to endure while in hell. Many people may be reluctant to admit how much they fear that they are sinners and could be destined to go to hell as well as the fear they hold that loved ones were sinners and are in hell. The fact that hell is forever, its hard to even imagine. Many may be uncomfortable outside on a hot day or sitting in a boring meeting, yet hell is portrayed far, far worse than these daily annoyances that many may try to avoid.

Religion also causes fear of supernatural horrors in this life, many people believe that witches, demons, or evil spirits are sabotaging their efforts or plotting to attack them. Normally, one would try to get a person to disbelieve in, or at least forget about, these sorts of paranoid delusions, however, if they are a member of a religion that accepts or even encourages these sorts of beliefs, it may be very difficult to convince someone to let go of them.

Religion can also cause fear of non-believers or believers in different religions, because it demands loyalty to a particular ideology, and that that ideology be defended against all conceivable threats. This fear leads to needless prejudice and sometimes even violence. Even "moderate" religionists are often afraid of the decline of their own faith, even they can't relate this decline to any definite tangible harm to themselves or others.

See also

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox