Pol Pot was an atheist

From Iron Chariots Wiki
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Cat (not a person))
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Yes, it is true that Pol Pot was an [[atheist]], but that did not make him a bad person, or influence him to make bad decisions.
+
===Background History===
Atheism is only the disbelief in God, not the belief in any dogma or rules. This means that Atheism is not a reason to kill, not for Pol Pot nor anyone. He can justifiably be accused of being a terrible human being, but his atheism, as a simple lack of belief, cannot be blamed for it.
+
  
Reply:
+
Pol Pot, also known as Saloth Sar, was the leader of the communist party of Cambodia from, and served as the Prime Minister from 1976-to 1979 in the Democratic Kampuchea. In his reign he attempted to purify Cambodia, through an Agrarian Socialism, which forced people to move into the country to restart Cambodian civilization. This led to a poor infrastructure and a mass genocide, killing 1.7 to 2.5 million people. With the poor quality of living and the mass murder of people, a total of 21% of the Cambodian population died. Pol Pot lost his power after the Vietnam invaded in 1979, during the Cambodian-Vietnam War. This forced him to flee into the southwestern jungle of the border between Cambodia and Thailand. Pol Pot died in 1998 under house arrest of the Ta Mok faction of the Khmer Rouge.
There is no way to exclude the fact that Atheism, or any belief, attributes certain mind sets that affect decisions; Pol Pot is no exception to this rule. His decisions were not induced out of thin air; instead, Pol Pot’s background and beliefs influenced his choices and actions. So atheism had a part to play in his conduct, but it would be incorrect to assume that atheism is the sole reason why Pol Pot became a mass murderer! There are too many subjective factors to his actions to come to a clear conclusion about this fact.
+
  
 +
===Apologetics===
  
[[Category:People]]
+
Apologists often point to people like Pol Pot, trying to make a point about atheism:
 +
 
 +
* Pol Pot was an evil murderer.
 +
* Pol Pot was an atheist.
 +
* Thus, Pol Pot's atheism has something to do with him being an evil murderer.
 +
* Therefore, atheism causes evil.
 +
 
 +
The point of the argument is to try establish that it's wrong to be an atheist, because if too many people are atheists, bad things will happen.
 +
 
 +
===Counter Apologetics===
 +
 
 +
This apologetic is an example of an [[association fallacy]]. If Pol Pot had a mustache, we wouldn't conclude that anyone with a mustache is like Pol Pot. This particular implementation of the fallacy is rampant, whether the example is Pol Pot, [[Stalin]] or [[Hitler]] (though he wasn't actually an atheist).
 +
 
 +
The claim that [[atheism causes evil]] is a subtle, but ultimately refutable claim.
 +
 
 +
[[Category:Criticisms of atheism]]

Latest revision as of 11:15, 12 March 2012

Background History

Pol Pot, also known as Saloth Sar, was the leader of the communist party of Cambodia from, and served as the Prime Minister from 1976-to 1979 in the Democratic Kampuchea. In his reign he attempted to purify Cambodia, through an Agrarian Socialism, which forced people to move into the country to restart Cambodian civilization. This led to a poor infrastructure and a mass genocide, killing 1.7 to 2.5 million people. With the poor quality of living and the mass murder of people, a total of 21% of the Cambodian population died. Pol Pot lost his power after the Vietnam invaded in 1979, during the Cambodian-Vietnam War. This forced him to flee into the southwestern jungle of the border between Cambodia and Thailand. Pol Pot died in 1998 under house arrest of the Ta Mok faction of the Khmer Rouge.

Apologetics

Apologists often point to people like Pol Pot, trying to make a point about atheism:

  • Pol Pot was an evil murderer.
  • Pol Pot was an atheist.
  • Thus, Pol Pot's atheism has something to do with him being an evil murderer.
  • Therefore, atheism causes evil.

The point of the argument is to try establish that it's wrong to be an atheist, because if too many people are atheists, bad things will happen.

Counter Apologetics

This apologetic is an example of an association fallacy. If Pol Pot had a mustache, we wouldn't conclude that anyone with a mustache is like Pol Pot. This particular implementation of the fallacy is rampant, whether the example is Pol Pot, Stalin or Hitler (though he wasn't actually an atheist).

The claim that atheism causes evil is a subtle, but ultimately refutable claim.

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox