Non sequitur

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Non-sequitur moved to Non sequitur: No dash required)
m (Construction of a Non-Sequitur: spelling)
Line 3: Line 3:
 
==Construction of a Non-Sequitur==
 
==Construction of a Non-Sequitur==
  
Non-sequiturs typically take the following forms:
+
Non sequiturs typically take the following forms:
  
 
# If A is true, B is true.
 
# If A is true, B is true.
Line 17: Line 17:
 
Even though both the premises and the conclusion are true, the argument is still a fallacy since the premises don't support the conclusion.
 
Even though both the premises and the conclusion are true, the argument is still a fallacy since the premises don't support the conclusion.
  
Another common non-sequiter is this:
+
Another common non sequitur is this:
  
 
# If A is true, then B is true.
 
# If A is true, then B is true.
Line 33: Line 33:
 
It's worth noting that if either of the above examples had said "If and only if A is true, then B is true" as their first premise, they would've been valid and non-fallacious but still unsound.
 
It's worth noting that if either of the above examples had said "If and only if A is true, then B is true" as their first premise, they would've been valid and non-fallacious but still unsound.
  
The above examples are the two main types of non-sequiter, however there are many other less common types.  An everyday example would be "If I wear my new shirt, all the girls will think I'm sexy."  However, not all girls will think that the same shirt looks sexy so there really isn't a connection between the two.  This type of non-sequitur is commonly seen in advertising.
+
The above examples are the two main types of non sequitur, however there are many other less common types.  An everyday example would be "If I wear my new shirt, all the girls will think I'm sexy."  However, not all girls will think that the same shirt looks sexy so there really isn't a connection between the two.  This type of non sequitur is commonly seen in advertising.
  
 
The two main premises above are good representations of the difference between [[validity vs. soundness|validity and soundness]].
 
The two main premises above are good representations of the difference between [[validity vs. soundness|validity and soundness]].

Revision as of 13:04, 31 August 2006

A non-sequitur (lit. "doesn't follow") is a logical fallacy in which the premises don't support the conclusion in any way. Thus, the conclusion doesn't follow from the premises.

Construction of a Non-Sequitur

Non sequiturs typically take the following forms:

  1. If A is true, B is true.
  2. B is stated to be true.
  3. Therefore, A is true.

Even if the both premises and the conclusion are true, the argument is still logically bad since the premises don't support the conclusion. For example:

  1. If I am human, then I'm a mammal.
  2. I am a mammal.
  3. Therefore, I'm human.

Even though both the premises and the conclusion are true, the argument is still a fallacy since the premises don't support the conclusion.

Another common non sequitur is this:

  1. If A is true, then B is true.
  2. A is not true.
  3. Therefore, B is not true.

Here's an example:

  1. If I am at home, then I'm in my bedroom.
  2. I'm not at home.
  3. Therefore, I'm not in my bedroom.

Again, the premises don't support the conclusion.

It's worth noting that if either of the above examples had said "If and only if A is true, then B is true" as their first premise, they would've been valid and non-fallacious but still unsound.

The above examples are the two main types of non sequitur, however there are many other less common types. An everyday example would be "If I wear my new shirt, all the girls will think I'm sexy." However, not all girls will think that the same shirt looks sexy so there really isn't a connection between the two. This type of non sequitur is commonly seen in advertising.

The two main premises above are good representations of the difference between validity and soundness.

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox