Islam

From Iron Chariots Wiki
(Redirected from Islamic)
Jump to: navigation, search
Wikipedia-logo-en.png
For more information, see the Wikipedia article:
Islamic women wearing niqab (left) and hijab (center and right), worn in more traditional cultures.
A mosque is a Muslim place of worship. This example in Libya has two minarets, a common feature in mosque architecture.
Muslims pray towards the Sacred Mosque in Mecca.
The Kaaba is at the center of the Sacred Mosque in Mecca and is considered to be the house of God and the holiest site in Islam

Islam is the predominant religion in the Middle East and is the second-largest religion in the world. Not limited to the Middle East, it has approximately 1.4 billion members, 80% of which are non-Arabs. It is one of the fastest growing religions in the world. Its adherents are called "Muslims" (also spelled Moslem), historically "Musselman", "Muhammedans", or even simply "Turks" in Europe and North America. In Arabic, a Muslim is "one who submits to God". Allah is simply the word God in Arabic.

Muslims, like Jews and Christians, are monotheistic and trace their roots to Abraham. However, they receive their instruction from the Qur'an (also spelled Koran). Islam's beginnings can be traced back to the 7th century under the leadership of Muhammad and his followers. Islam is largely based on pre-existing Arabian paganism, Jewish, Christian and Zoroastrian influences. [1] [2] The vast majority of Muslims also consider haddith literature, the traditional teachings and sayings of Muhammad, as secondary religious scripture.

An universalizing (evangelizing) religion, it spread throughout the world by military conquest and Muslim missionaries. The moral and legal code of Islam is called Sharia law, which has received widespread criticism for its anachronistic and unjust laws and barbaric punishments.

Contents

Five pillars of Islam

There are five principles that are generally considered mandatory practices by Muslims:

  • There is only one god Allah. Muhammad is his (greatest and final) messenger/prophet.
  • Prayer five times a day, facing in the direction of Mecca.
  • Tithing, including 2.5% of capital assets.
  • Fasting and holiness during the holy month of Ramadan.
  • Pilgrimage to Mecca at least once, if possible. (Hajj)

Branches

The main sects within Islam are Sunni (~80% of Muslims) and Shia (10-20%). The two denominations grew out of a split over who was to succeed leadership after Muhammad. [3] There are several minority branches outside mainstream Islam, including:

Other movements within Islam:

  • Sufi
  • The Salafi movement is a traditionalist sect and sometimes considered part of Sunni Islam.
    • Radical or Extremist Salafism is an extremist, traditionalist variant of Sunni Islam and is followed by Islamist groups such as al-Qaeda and Islamic State.
  • Quranism, rejects the authority of hadith.
  • Wahhabi, an traditionalist variant of Sunni Islam. It has largely been incorporated into Salafism but was perhaps the first Salafist movement in the modern era.

Criticism

Wikipedia-logo-en.png
For more information, see the Wikipedia article:

"We have to acknowledge that Islam has doctrines like jihād and martyrdom and death to apostates which are central to the faith in which they aren't in other faiths"

Sam Harris [4]

Sharia law

Main Article: Sharia law

Sharia law is based upon a literal interpretation of the Qur'an and the hadith; being extrapolated upon where required by Fiqh - which is Islamic jurisprudence. The extrapolations may vary depending on the sect and the school of thought followed by different scholars, however the core laws of Sharia remain the same across the different schools of fiqh and the sects. Sharia law is widely criticised for containing unjust laws and mandating cruel punishments.

Fundamentalism

Skeptics Annotated Quran.jpg
For more information, see the Skeptic's Annotated Quran article:

Islamic fundamentalism is fairly strong in middle-eastern regions, one result being the oppression of women. Spurred by, though unlikely exclusively due to, inflammatory passages of the Qur'an, there have been instances of terrorism in the name of Islam, including suicide bombings, beheadings and public stonings.[5][6] Many Muslim fundamentalists adhere to a traditionalist Salafi interpretation of Islam. Some terrorist organizations follow or promote an extreme version of Salafi Islam.

Moderate Muslims are more prevalent in Europe. However, there are still a minority of extremists who campaign and protest with the intent of silencing criticism of Islam and Muhammed. The protection of religion from criticism, sometimes referred to as "religious defamation", is incompatible with liberal norms such as freedom of speech.

Similar to other religions, ideas promoted by mainstream Islam may leave people susceptible to radicalization.

Accusations of violence

Islam is often called a "religion of peace" but the Qur'an contains many violent quotations. [7] Most contemporary Muslims believe there is no religious obligation to use force to spread Islam. In 2011, a Gallup poll found that 78% of American Muslims believe that violence that kills civilians is never justified. This makes Muslims less bloodthirsty than Christians (38%-39%) or atheists (56%). [8]

"The horror of our circumstance is that it is very difficult to say how ISIS is distorting the central teachings of Islam. If you read the Qur'an, if you read the Hadith, if you read the biography of Muhammad and you ask yourself what is ISIS doing that Muhammad wouldn't do or would have clearly objected to. That is not an easy question to answer. [...] If he lead by example, if Muhammad was the best person who ever lived well then it gets you something very close to ISIS. And then we are having to read the fine print to find how it doesn't apply in our time. Now, anyone who is not admitting this is either an ignoramus or is lying about Islam and that is a huge problem. When our President [Obama] gets up and says ISIS is not Islamic and he refuses to use the word Islam in any other context and he talks as if we are at war with a generic terrorism, as though we might be at war with the IRA, people get the sense they are being lied to. [...] It's only the secularist, and the atheist, and the moderate, and the person who has had his purchase on this kind of medieval theology relaxed by all that we enjoy in the modern world, only that person is left thinking 'well may be it is not really religion, may be they don't believe what they say they believe'. No, it's religion!"

Sam Harris[9]

Most contemporary Muslims believe there is no religious obligation to use force to spread Islam.

False association with terrorism

Wikipedia-logo-en.png
For more information, see the Wikipedia article:

Muslims are often accused of being potential terrorists by certain media and political sources. This is questionable because the vast majority of Muslims are non-violent, particularly within stable societies. This implies terrorism is instead a result of social and political circumstances. Writers such as Sam Harris have argued that there are some Islamic concepts, such as jihād and martyrdom are helpful concepts for terrorist groups to legitimise their tactics; however it is important to realise that any ideological system can have an extremist or violent interpretation.

The false association of Muslims and terrorism also overlooks the stronger association between Christianity and terror. [10] Ideologically motivated Christians that use force to achieve political or social aims are routinely called "criminals" rather than "terrorists", even though a Muslim who performed the same acts would be branded a terrorist. In recent years, more terrorist attacks in the US have been by religiously motivated Christians rather than Muslims. [11][12]

Controversial practices

There are some traditional Islamic practices that are not clearly or explicitly specified in Sharia law but are still characteristic of Islam.

Islam has traditionally encouraged women to wear head coverings, such as a Hijab. Young girls are excluded from this practice. Sharia law states that people should dress modestly but is unclear as that what is required for modesty. [13] Adoption of this practice is largely influenced by culture, with some cultures imposing pressure not to wear the headscarf. The Turkish government has banned headscarves in public office or at universities. [14]

More fundamentalist interpretations of Islam practice gender segregation for non-relatives.

Possible incompatibility with an open society

Skeptics Annotated Quran.jpg
For more information, see the Skeptic's Annotated Quran article:

Islam was conceived as a system that governs both spiritual and Earthly matters. It has a number of practices that function as a state, including taxation and a legal code. Some observers argue that this makes Islam incompatible with the separation of church and state. This is one of the core principles of an open society. A state having an official religion tends to alienate those who do not agree with this view. Also, the established religion often undermines other aspects of an open society, such as democracy, separation of legislature and judiciary, introducing religious tests, etc.

"[...] Islam, perhaps more than other monotheistic religions, invites itself into every aspect of social life. More specifically, Islam is inherently and by definition inconsistent with the separation of church and state. [15]"
"The most difficult part of Islamic Law for most westerners to grasp is that there is no separation of church and state. The religion of Islam and the government are one. Islamic Law is controlled, ruled and regulated by the Islamic religion. The theocracy controls all public and private matters. Government, law and religion are one. [16]"
"Even though ideologically [in Islam] there can be no separation between church and state, both Sunnis and Shiites developed a separation very early on. In the Sunni world, the separation was de facto; Islamic law developed as kind of a counterculture to the aristocratic courts. In the Shiite world, there was a separation of church and state on principle. It was held that since every state was corrupt, clerics should take no part in them, that the religious should withdraw until the messiah came and established a proper Muslim state. [17]"

Compromise is necessary in democracies, particularly when drafting laws. It is difficult to achieve a consensus when one party believes they have an objectively perfect legal system. Islam also does not recognize equality under the law, as different laws apply depending on a person's religious beliefs.

Fatalistic

Islam has a strong tradition of fatalism which arguably stifles human initiative.

"Human agency and human freedom are nullified. [...] Why should human effort strive by sanitary means to prevent disease, when death or life depends in no way on such measures but upon the will of Allah? [18]"

Other apologetics

Islam is not a religion

"Islam is a political ideology, it definitely hides behind this notion of it being a religion [...] It’s like cancer. It's like a malignant cancer in this case.[19]"
So to reiterate – Islam is not a religion because:
  1. It is an amalgam of social, political and judicial systems as well as a belief system. It is neither one thing nor the other – Islam is unique
  2. Philosophically it is as far from other religions as it is possible to be. It lies beyond nihilism and its morality is inverted.
  3. In society Islam functions in the opposite manner from all other religions. Rather than producing peace and social harmony, it sows violence and social disruption.[20]
By any reasonable definition of religion, Islam is one. Of course, Islam arguably addresses more aspects of a believer's life than some other religions, but that doesn't make it not a religion. (Although Christians would also claim that their religion comprehensively addresses all aspects of human life.) Saying it is either a religion or a political system is a false dichotomy and an equivocation over the word "religion". The Old Testament contains a fairly broad legal code but that doesn't mean Judaism isn't a religion. Other religions are also harmful, particularly when a historical view of Christianity is considered.
"It’s extremely important to note that one of the main things separating a true religion from a cult is that NO true religion instructs its followers to kill in God's name, but many a cult instructs its followers to kill in the name of their leader. Such is the case with the cult known as islam."

This is the no true Scotsman fallacy and displays ignorance of that is in the Old Testament. Related claims include "Christianity is not a religion" and "Atheism is a religion".

Practices

Pilgrimage

Arbae'en is an annual festival within Shia Islam. It attracts up to 20 million pilgrims to Karbala, Iraq over several days, making it one of the largest pilgrimages in the world. [21] This is far larger than the Hajj pilgrimage to Mecca which visits Islam's two most holy sites.

References

  1. [1]
  2. [2]
  3. [3]
  4. CNN, Harris: Islam is "mother lode" of bad ideas, 13 Oct 2014
  5. [4]
  6. [5]
  7. Just a few of many violent quotes from the Qur'an
  8. [6]
  9. [7]
  10. [8]
  11. [9]
  12. [10]
  13. [11]
  14. [12]
  15. [13]
  16. [14]
  17. [15]
  18. [16]
  19. RWW News: Michael Flynn: Islam Is A 'Cancer,' 'Political Ideology' That 'Hides Behind' Religion
  20. [17]
  21. [18]

See also

External links

Videos

Websites


v · d Religion
v · d Abrahamic religions
Abrahamic Religions   Baha'i · Christianity · Christian Science · Druze · Islam · Jehovah's Witnesses · Judaism · Mandaeism · Mormonism · Samaritanism · Rastafarianism


v · d Dharmic religions
Dharmic Religions   Buddhism · Hinduism · Jainism · Sikhism · Zoroastrianism


v · d Folk religions
African folk religions   African traditional religion · Santeria · Egyptian mythology
North American folk religions   Inuit mythology


v · d New religious movements
    Mormonism · Jehovah's Witnesses · Scientology


v · d Taoic religions
Taoic religions   Shinto · Taoism · Confucianism · Caodaism · Chondogyo · Chen Tao · Jeung San Do · Yiguandao
Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox