Iron Chariots Wiki:Editing guidelines

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(big rewrite/reformat/reorganization begun -- back later to finish)
(still going through, doing rewrites/reformatting... back later)
Line 2: Line 2:
  
 
==General guidelines==
 
==General guidelines==
* '''DO''' use [[Wikipedia:|Wikipedia]] as the gold standard.
+
* '''DO''' use [[Wikipedia:|Wikipedia]] as the [[Wiktionary:gold standard|gold standard]].
 
*: They've been at this a long time. When in doubt about style, [[Wikipedia:WP:MOS|check out how they do it]] and, if necessary, adapt it to this wiki.
 
*: They've been at this a long time. When in doubt about style, [[Wikipedia:WP:MOS|check out how they do it]] and, if necessary, adapt it to this wiki.
 
* '''DON'T''' plagiarize Wikipedia... unless you have to.
 
* '''DON'T''' plagiarize Wikipedia... unless you have to.
*: We recognize that Wikipedia articles are sometimes the best source for information about certain topics, but our [[Project:Copyright|copyright policy]] is different from theirs, so don't just cut-and-paste an entire article to this wiki (even with attribution, this is just not good editing style). Try to reword, summarize, edit, and generally adapt the information to meet [[Project:Introduction|our goals]] here at '''Iron Chariots'''.
+
*: We recognize that Wikipedia articles are sometimes an excellent source for information about certain topics, but our [[Project:Copyright|copyright policy]] is different from theirs, so don't just cut-and-paste an entire article to this wiki (even with attribution, this is just not good editing style). Try to reword, summarize, edit, and generally adapt the information to meet [[Project:Introduction|our goals]] here at '''Iron Chariots'''.
 
* '''DO''' check out other sources of information.
 
* '''DO''' check out other sources of information.
 
*: See our [[Project:Interwiki map (full)|Interwiki map]] for some particularly useful sites.
 
*: See our [[Project:Interwiki map (full)|Interwiki map]] for some particularly useful sites.
Line 13: Line 13:
 
==Editing tips==
 
==Editing tips==
 
* '''DON'T''' use HTML code unless it's absolutely necessary.
 
* '''DON'T''' use HTML code unless it's absolutely necessary.
*: If all you want to do is write ''italic'' or '''bold''' text, the [[WikimediaMeta:Help:Wikitext examples|wiki markup]] looks like this:
+
*: Many HTML constructs have wiki equivalents. If all you want to do is write ''italic'' or '''bold''' text, for example, the [[WikimediaMeta:Help:Wikitext examples|wiki markup]] looks like this:
 
*:* <tt><nowiki>''italic''</nowiki></tt> (double-apostrophes in front and behind)
 
*:* <tt><nowiki>''italic''</nowiki></tt> (double-apostrophes in front and behind)
 
*:* <tt><nowiki>'''bold'''</nowiki></tt> (triple)
 
*:* <tt><nowiki>'''bold'''</nowiki></tt> (triple)
Line 23: Line 23:
 
*: Link to external websites by using "single-brackets":
 
*: Link to external websites by using "single-brackets":
 
*:* <tt><nowiki>[http://www.infidels.org/library/ The SecularWeb Library]</nowiki></tt> &rarr; [http://www.infidels.org/library/ The SecularWeb Library]
 
*:* <tt><nowiki>[http://www.infidels.org/library/ The SecularWeb Library]</nowiki></tt> &rarr; [http://www.infidels.org/library/ The SecularWeb Library]
*: For other examples of wiki markup, see [[WikimediaMeta:Help:Wikitext examples]].
+
*: For other examples of wiki markup, including lists and tables, see [[WikimediaMeta:Help:Wikitext examples]].
 
* '''DO''' mark minor edits.
 
* '''DO''' mark minor edits.
 
*: Remember to check the "minor edit" box before you submit a typo fix or other small change. The rule of thumb is that if you don't change any actual information in the article, or the way it's organized, then it's a minor edit. Most changes to spelling and punctuation would be minor. Changing any fact/assertion in the article, even a small one, is not minor.
 
*: Remember to check the "minor edit" box before you submit a typo fix or other small change. The rule of thumb is that if you don't change any actual information in the article, or the way it's organized, then it's a minor edit. Most changes to spelling and punctuation would be minor. Changing any fact/assertion in the article, even a small one, is not minor.
* '''DO''' use the "preview" feature.
+
*:* "Atheist commedien Pen Jilette..." &rarr; "Atheist co<u>m</u>edi<u>a</u>n Pe<u>nn</u> Ji<u>ll</u>ette..." &mdash; '''minor'''
*: Sometimes the first attempt to change an article doesn't come out the way you expected. To avoid having to edit a page multiple times, use the "{{MediaWiki:showpreview}}" and "{{MediaWiki:showdiff}}" buttons before committing to your changes (by choosing "{{MediaWiki:savearticle}}").
+
*:* "Theist comedian Penn Jillette..." &rarr; "<u>A</u>theist comedian Penn Jillette..." &mdash; '''not minor'''
 +
* '''DO''' use the special editing "preview" features.
 +
*: Sometimes the first attempt to change an article doesn't come out the way you expected. To avoid having to edit a page multiple times, use the "'''{{MediaWiki:showpreview}}'''" button before committing to your changes (by choosing "{{MediaWiki:savearticle}}"). The "'''{{MediaWiki:showdiff}}'''" button is helpful for creating informative [[WikimediaMeta:Help:Edit summary|edit summaries]] (after a lot of editing, it's easy to forget what changes you've actually made).
  
 
==Links==
 
==Links==
* '''DO''' <nowiki>[[link]]</nowiki> the first occurrence of each key word or phrase.
+
* '''DO''' <nowiki>[[link]]</nowiki> the first occurrence of each '''significant''' word or phrase in an article.
*: Please do this even if the article doesn't exist yet, as long as it should in the future (see also the [[#Creating new articles|article naming conventions below]]).
+
*: "Significant" means something that ''should'' have an article here at this wiki, whether it does or not. (See also the [[#Creating new articles|article naming conventions below]]).
 
* '''DON'T''' link subsequent occurrences, unless not doing so would significantly inconvenience the reader.
 
* '''DON'T''' link subsequent occurrences, unless not doing so would significantly inconvenience the reader.
*: A second, or even third, link may be warranted if the they are well separated on the page and the subsequent instances would seem to require a link more than the previous one(s). In other words, don't make people go searching for the "missing link" (no pun intended) when they come across a significant word or phrase they might want to look up. Just don't overdo the linking.
+
*: A second, or even third, link may be warranted if the they are far apart in a long article and the later instance(s) would benefit from linking even more than the previous one(s). In other words, don't make people go searching in the article for the "missing link" (no pun intended) when they come across a term they;ll probably want more information about. Just don't overdo the linking.
* '''DO''' make redirection pages, as needed.
+
* '''DO''' prefer internal links to external (see the distinction [[#Editing tips|above]]).
 +
*: Except for special cases, like Bible verses (for which [[Template:Bible|a special template]] exists) or topics that should ''not'' have articles here (because they are too off-topic), links in articles should be to other articles here at '''Iron Chariots''' whenever possible. If the article doesn't exist yet, it's sometimes a judgment call: readers would probably prefer an external link to none at all, yet editors would prefer to see the "redlink" (see "[[This is not an article.]]" example above) so they know [[Special:Wantedpages|an article on the topic is lacking]].
 +
* '''DO''' prefer singular page names to plural, when appropriate.
 +
*: That is, when linking a plural word like "atheists" in article text, link only the "atheist" part, leaving the "s" outside of the double-brackets:
 +
*:* <tt><nowiki>[[atheist]]s</nowiki></tt> &rarr; [[atheist]]s
 +
*: There are exceptions, of course, such as the word "apologetics", where the singular form("apologetic") means something completely different.
 +
* '''DON'T''' create misleading links.
 +
*: It's occasionally okay to use this format: <nowiki>"[[evidence|standards of evidence]]"</nowiki>.  The text will show up as "standards of evidence", but the link goes to the article on "evidence", so the text differs from the link. In general, though, you should be sparing with this technique. If the words that you want to link are a subset of the words in the text, then you can reduce the link like this: <nowiki>"Standards of [[evidence]]".</nowiki> If the link is actually a synonym for the word displayed, consider setting up a #REDIRECT page so the link will happen automatically without using redirection within the text. If a redirection page doesn't make sense, maybe you don't really need to be making a link to the article you have in mind all. Or maybe you can work in a way to display the proper term elsewhere in your article, and make a regular link out of it. Remember, you only need to link a term once in each article.
 +
* '''DO''' create redirection pages, as needed.
 
*: Link words that mean nearly the same thing as an existing entry. For instance: <nowiki>"Many [[apologists]] believe blah blah blah."</nowiki> Then follow the apologists link to edit that page and add this text: <nowiki>"#REDIRECT [[apologetics]]"</nowiki> (leave off the quotation marks).  Of course, in this case the redirect is [http://wiki.ironchariots.org/index.php?title=Apologists&redirect=no already in place].
 
*: Link words that mean nearly the same thing as an existing entry. For instance: <nowiki>"Many [[apologists]] believe blah blah blah."</nowiki> Then follow the apologists link to edit that page and add this text: <nowiki>"#REDIRECT [[apologetics]]"</nowiki> (leave off the quotation marks).  Of course, in this case the redirect is [http://wiki.ironchariots.org/index.php?title=Apologists&redirect=no already in place].
 
* '''DON'T''' create "double redirects".
 
* '''DON'T''' create "double redirects".
 
*: These are redirect pages that point to other redirect pages. The [http://www.mediawiki.org/ MediaWiki software] will not follow multiple (i.e., chained) redirects. Always ''check the redirect you just created'' to make sure it points to an actual article.
 
*: These are redirect pages that point to other redirect pages. The [http://www.mediawiki.org/ MediaWiki software] will not follow multiple (i.e., chained) redirects. Always ''check the redirect you just created'' to make sure it points to an actual article.
* '''DON'T''' create misleading links.
 
*: It's occasionally okay to use this format: <nowiki>"[[evidence|standards of evidence]]"</nowiki>.  The text will show up as "standards of evidence", but the link goes to the article on "evidence", so the text differs from the link. In general, though, you should be sparing with this technique. If the words that you want to link are a subset of the words in the text, then you can reduce the link like this: <nowiki>"Standards of [[evidence]]".</nowiki> If the link is actually a synonym for the word displayed, consider setting up a #REDIRECT page so the link will happen automatically without using redirection within the text. If a redirection page doesn't make sense, maybe you don't really need to be making a link to the article you have in mind all. Or maybe you can work in a way to display the proper term elsewhere in your article, and make a regular link out of it. Remember, you only need to link a term once in each article.
 
* '''DO''' prefer singular page names to plural, when appropriate.
 
*: That is, when linking a word like ''atheists'' in article text, try <nowiki>"[[atheist]]s"</nowiki> first; this links to the page called [[Atheist]], but includes the "s" in the linked text. There are exceptions, of course, such as the <nowiki>"[[apologetics]]"</nowiki> example above ("apologetic" is something completely different).
 
  
 
==Creating new articles==
 
==Creating new articles==
* '''DO''' start new articles by linking from other articles (see how [[#Links|below]]).
+
* '''DO''' start new articles by linking from other articles.
*: Although there are other ways to do it, creating an article by linking (see below) a word in an existing aricle is the best way to avoid [[Special:Lonelypages|"orphaned" articles]].
+
*: Although there are other ways to do it, creating an article by linking (see how [[#Editing tips|above]]) a word or phrase in an existing aricle is the best way to avoid [[Special:Lonelypages|"orphaned" articles]] (those not linked to from any other page on the wiki).
 
* '''DO''' prefer "sentence style" capitalization.
 
* '''DO''' prefer "sentence style" capitalization.
 
*: For multiple-word article titles, capitalize only words that would need it if the phrase were used in an ordinary sentence. The purpose of this guideline is, of course, to facilitate linking in [[Project:running text|running text]]. For example:
 
*: For multiple-word article titles, capitalize only words that would need it if the phrase were used in an ordinary sentence. The purpose of this guideline is, of course, to facilitate linking in [[Project:running text|running text]]. For example:

Revision as of 19:27, 1 March 2007

Here are some DOs and DON'Ts to get you started on editing articles here on Iron Chariots.

Contents

General guidelines

  • DO use Wikipedia as the gold standard.
    They've been at this a long time. When in doubt about style, check out how they do it and, if necessary, adapt it to this wiki.
  • DON'T plagiarize Wikipedia... unless you have to.
    We recognize that Wikipedia articles are sometimes an excellent source for information about certain topics, but our copyright policy is different from theirs, so don't just cut-and-paste an entire article to this wiki (even with attribution, this is just not good editing style). Try to reword, summarize, edit, and generally adapt the information to meet our goals here at Iron Chariots.
  • DO check out other sources of information.
    See our Interwiki map for some particularly useful sites.
  • DO read our statement on the neutral point of view.
    Our version is not the same as Wikipedia's, but we do have standards.

Editing tips

  • DON'T use HTML code unless it's absolutely necessary.
    Many HTML constructs have wiki equivalents. If all you want to do is write italic or bold text, for example, the wiki markup looks like this:
    • ''italic'' (double-apostrophes in front and behind)
    • '''bold''' (triple)
    • '''''bold italic''''' (5 apostrophes — use sparingly)
  • DO link to other articles and external sources.
    Link to another article here at Iron Chariots by using "double-brackets" wiki markup:
    Link to external websites by using "single-brackets":
    For other examples of wiki markup, including lists and tables, see WikimediaMeta:Help:Wikitext examples.
  • DO mark minor edits.
    Remember to check the "minor edit" box before you submit a typo fix or other small change. The rule of thumb is that if you don't change any actual information in the article, or the way it's organized, then it's a minor edit. Most changes to spelling and punctuation would be minor. Changing any fact/assertion in the article, even a small one, is not minor.
    • "Atheist commedien Pen Jilette..." → "Atheist comedian Penn Jillette..." — minor
    • "Theist comedian Penn Jillette..." → "Atheist comedian Penn Jillette..." — not minor
  • DO use the special editing "preview" features.
    Sometimes the first attempt to change an article doesn't come out the way you expected. To avoid having to edit a page multiple times, use the "Show preview" button before committing to your changes (by choosing "Save page"). The "Show changes" button is helpful for creating informative edit summaries (after a lot of editing, it's easy to forget what changes you've actually made).

Links

  • DO [[link]] the first occurrence of each significant word or phrase in an article.
    "Significant" means something that should have an article here at this wiki, whether it does or not. (See also the article naming conventions below).
  • DON'T link subsequent occurrences, unless not doing so would significantly inconvenience the reader.
    A second, or even third, link may be warranted if the they are far apart in a long article and the later instance(s) would benefit from linking even more than the previous one(s). In other words, don't make people go searching in the article for the "missing link" (no pun intended) when they come across a term they;ll probably want more information about. Just don't overdo the linking.
  • DO prefer internal links to external (see the distinction above).
    Except for special cases, like Bible verses (for which a special template exists) or topics that should not have articles here (because they are too off-topic), links in articles should be to other articles here at Iron Chariots whenever possible. If the article doesn't exist yet, it's sometimes a judgment call: readers would probably prefer an external link to none at all, yet editors would prefer to see the "redlink" (see "This is not an article." example above) so they know an article on the topic is lacking.
  • DO prefer singular page names to plural, when appropriate.
    That is, when linking a plural word like "atheists" in article text, link only the "atheist" part, leaving the "s" outside of the double-brackets:
    There are exceptions, of course, such as the word "apologetics", where the singular form("apologetic") means something completely different.
  • DON'T create misleading links.
    It's occasionally okay to use this format: "[[evidence|standards of evidence]]". The text will show up as "standards of evidence", but the link goes to the article on "evidence", so the text differs from the link. In general, though, you should be sparing with this technique. If the words that you want to link are a subset of the words in the text, then you can reduce the link like this: "Standards of [[evidence]]". If the link is actually a synonym for the word displayed, consider setting up a #REDIRECT page so the link will happen automatically without using redirection within the text. If a redirection page doesn't make sense, maybe you don't really need to be making a link to the article you have in mind all. Or maybe you can work in a way to display the proper term elsewhere in your article, and make a regular link out of it. Remember, you only need to link a term once in each article.
  • DO create redirection pages, as needed.
    Link words that mean nearly the same thing as an existing entry. For instance: "Many [[apologists]] believe blah blah blah." Then follow the apologists link to edit that page and add this text: "#REDIRECT [[apologetics]]" (leave off the quotation marks). Of course, in this case the redirect is already in place.
  • DON'T create "double redirects".
    These are redirect pages that point to other redirect pages. The MediaWiki software will not follow multiple (i.e., chained) redirects. Always check the redirect you just created to make sure it points to an actual article.

Creating new articles

  • DO start new articles by linking from other articles.
    Although there are other ways to do it, creating an article by linking (see how above) a word or phrase in an existing aricle is the best way to avoid "orphaned" articles (those not linked to from any other page on the wiki).
  • DO prefer "sentence style" capitalization.
    For multiple-word article titles, capitalize only words that would need it if the phrase were used in an ordinary sentence. The purpose of this guideline is, of course, to facilitate linking in running text. For example:
    If necessary, you can always #REDIRECT pages with different capitalization to a canonical version.
  • DO use "sentence style" capitalization on section headers, too.
    That is, use a header like "Content guidelines", not "Content Guidelines".
  • DO remember to add a category to new articles.
    This is accomplished by adding a special link of the form [[Category:Category name]] to the bottom of the article (although technically it doesn't matter where it appears in the wikitext). Most subjects have a category if you think hard enough, and maybe several (multiple categories each require their own separate "Category:" link). You can check the list of categories to see if one is relevant, or just try a few general ones (e.g., Category:Atheism, Category:People, Category:Arguments) and navigate down from there to the most specific, relevant category you can find (obviously, this method will be easier once the category structure has been fleshed out a bit more).
  • DO create new categories if they don't already exist.
    If no existing category seems to fit for an article, create a new one by simply using it in an article (see previous "DO"). The link will indicate that the category is missing (a "redlink" for most users) until you actually create the category page itself; do this the same way you create an article, by following the link and adding some text. Most categories don't really require any explanation, but every category should be a member of another, parent category (except for the top-most, "root" category, of course). Thus, all you need for most category pages is a "Category:" link to an appropriate parent category.
  • DON'T create "stub" articles just because you don't like seeing red text.
    The red text serves as a helpful flag letting people know that an article is lacking. It is acceptable to create a stub article if you have one piece of genuinely useful information, such as an external link or a well-written summary. It is not a good idea to create a three word phrase and call that a stub article.
  • DON'T duplicate text on multiple pages if you can help it.
    If the information changes in some way, it is a real pain to edit the same thing in two places, and it's a maintenance nightmare if two similar articles are out of sync. Instead, figure out which page is the best place to put what you really want to say, and make sure that the link from the other page stands out. Example: the page on omnipotence used to include a discussion of the omnipotence paradox. Now, it merely mentions the paradox and links to it.

This page

  • DO feel free to edit this page.
    This is a community effort and we're all learning. If you'd rather post your suggestion on the "talk" page, you can do that instead.
Personal tools
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox