Faith healing

From Iron Chariots Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Wikipedia-logo-en.png
For more information, see the Wikipedia article:

Faith healing refers to the healing of diseases, infirmities, etc., by supernatural means. In modern times, many Christian evangelists have claimed to have this ability. Some Christians have cited them as powerful evidence for the existence of God and the truth of Christianity. However, investigations of faith healers by men such as doctor William Nolen and magician James Randi have failed to find any evidence of actual miracles, and have turned up much evidence of fraud or, at best, self-deception.

Contents

Methods

The methods by which faith healers convince others of their powers can be divided into two groups: those that do not require conscious trickery on the part of the healer and those that do.

Without trickery

In his investigation of Kathryn Kuhlman, Nolen came to the conclusion that she was probably sincere. His observations of her patients suggest a number of ways in which a healer could come to falsely believe in his or her powers:[1]

  • One man got up out of a wheelchair, but having met the man earlier, Nolen knew he had merely found walking difficult, not impossible. The man was back in his wheelchair after the service.
  • One 20-year old girl came up on stage to claim a cure for polio, but as a doctor Nolen could see that she was obviously not cured. However, both Kuhlman and her audience seemed equally oblivious to this fact.
  • Follow ups of patients with diseases that can improve naturally, such as multiple sclerosis, migraines, and bursitis resulted in patients claiming cures based on improvement but not total recovery, and even the extent of the improvement was unclear.
  • Follow ups of patients who had claimed cures for cancer found that they all still had cancer afterwards, and in at least two cases the patient died shortly after visiting Kuhlman.

In summarizing his investigation, Nolen concluded:[1]

"The problem is, and I'm sorry this has to be so blunt, one of ignorance. Miss Kuhlman doesn't know the difference between psychogenic and organic diseases; she doesn't know anything about hypnotism and the power of suggestion; she doesn't know anything about the autonomic nervous system."

Thus, her lack of knowledge prevented her from accurately assessing what was going on in the people who came to her for help.

Involving trickery

One of the main types of deception used by faith healers is faking miraculous knowledge of the ailments people come to them for. This can be done by having people write down their ailments on sealed slips whose contents are revealed using a standard magician's trick known as the "one ahead trick." It can also be done by having assistants pump clients for information, which the healer may then commit to memory, put into notes, or be delivered by a secret radio receiver. The latter was the method used by Peter Popoff, whom James Randi exposed by using an electronic eavesdropping system to record the radio messages. This recording was then played over a tape of one of Popoff's performances on Johnny Carson's Tonight Show.

Another common trick is known as leg-lengthening, where the healer claims the patient has one leg longer than the other and then purports to correct the problem right before the audience's eyes. To those not familiar with the trick, it can seem like an undeniable miracle, but it is in fact a variant of a standard carnival trick and is explained in great detail in James Randi's book The Faith Healers.[2]

Criticism

Healing of Limb Amputation

Many medical conditions, including death [3], are difficult to establish with absolute certainty. However, limb amputation is usually easy to confirm and a replacement limb never spontaneously regenerates in humans, according to current scientific understanding. Because of its unambiguity, limb amputation makes an excellent case study of miracle healing.

If miracle healing occurs, there is no reason they should not occur for amputated limbs. However, there is a conspicuous lack of evidence that miracle healing of missing limbs occurs. This suggests that healing miracles do not occur at all and their testimony is due to coincidences, hoaxes and self-delusion.

Ray Comfort attempts to defuse this argument by pointing out that this may have occurred but we are not aware of it. [4] If this had occurred, there would be medical records, expert witnesses and the recovered patient as evidence. Because of the significance of the event, it would be widely reported and it would be widely known. However, the lack of reliable testimony throughout history suggests this type of healing has never occurred.

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 Nolen, William A. Healing: A Doctor In Search of a Miracle New York: Random House, 1974.
  2. Randi, James. The Faith Healers Prometheus Books, 1989.
  3. Huff Post, "Walter Williams Wakes Up In Body Bag At Morgue", 28th Feb 2014 [1]
  4. Ray Comfort, "The Defender's Guide For Life's Toughest Questions", p. 19

External Links


v · d Skepticism
Religion   Afterlife · God · Soul · Angel · Demon · Prayer · Satan · Miracle · Exorcism
Paranormal   Witchcraft · Ghost · Mythical creatures · ESP · Faith healing · Near-death experience · Magic · Spirit
Superstitions   Astrology · Divinitation · Luck · Curse · Prophecy · Palmistry · Charms · Occult · Rain dance · Immanent end of the world
Pseudoscience   Alternate medicine · Reiki · Chiropractic · Homeopathy · Autism-Vaccine debate · Demonology · Angeology
Notable skeptics   Carl Sagan · James Randi · Michael Shermer · Issac Asimov · Richard Dawkins · Harriet A. Hall · Robert T. Carrol · Benjamin Radford
Arguments for the supernatural   You can't prove a negative · You can't prove God doesn't exist · God can't be defined · All the world's religions can't be wrong
Arguments against the supernatural   Outsider test
Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox