Belief

From Iron Chariots Wiki
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(expanding; might need to split off "degree of belief" section to own article? -- have to stop in middle; more to come...)
(Resurrected deleted material)
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Belief''', in simplest terms, is what the [[mind]] accepts as [[true]]. One can believe something to be true without having [[knowledge]] that it is true. Also, one can believe something to varying degrees of certainty (see also [[Probability]]).
+
{{wikipedia|color=#F0FFD5;}}
 +
{{wiktionary|belief|color=#F0FFD5;}}
 +
'''Belief''' or '''believing''', in simplest terms, is the acceptance by the [[mind]] of something as [[true]]. '''<u>A</u> belief''' is something which is believed. One can believe something to be true without having [[knowledge]] that it is true. Also, one can believe something to varying degrees of certainty (see also [[Probability]]).
  
==Degree of belief==
+
Calling someone a '''believer''' often connotes belief in a [[god]], especially the [[Christian]] God (in the U.S., anyway). There are many reasons people give for their belief in their god/s. Some amount to, “When I go outside and I look around I can only think god did it all.”  Sometimes, though, the belief is related to some other [[supernatural]] or unsupported claim, such as [[ESP]] or [[alien abduction]] &mdash; or even to a philosophical position or political opinion.
  
Common phrases describing ones own degree of belief:
+
==Degrees of belief==
 +
 
 +
Common phrases describing one's own degree of belief:
 
* I ''know'' that
 
* I ''know'' that
 
* I ''believe'' that
 
* I ''believe'' that
Line 29: Line 33:
 
* It ''can/could be'' true
 
* It ''can/could be'' true
  
In addition, most of the above statements could be negated in two different ways, giving rise to different connotations. For example, "It is ''not likely'' [to be] true" is different from "It is ''likely not'' [to be] true".
+
In addition, most of the above statements could be negated in two different ways, giving rise to different connotations. For example, "It is ''not likely'' true" is different from "It is ''likely not'' true".
  
==Belief vs. faith==
+
==Disbelief==
  
Believing something without evidence (or in the face of contradictory evidence) is often called ''[[faith]]''. "Belief" does not always imply "faith," as one can believe something based on evidence or other rational reasons (e.g., logical arguments).
+
The word ''disbelief'' has two possible connotations:
 +
# lack of, or absence of, belief
 +
# belief to the contrary
  
For example, one does not need to have faith that the sun will rise tomorrow, since the [[fact]] that the sun rises every day is supported by a lifetime of personal experience, thousands of years worth of recorded observation, and a scientific model of the earth's rotation on its axis.
+
The two connotations are at the heart of the confusion between [[weak atheism]] (lack of belief in any gods) and [[strong atheism]] (positive belief that there are no gods).
 +
 
 +
See also [[Atheist vs. agnostic]] and [[Absolute certainty]].
 +
 
 +
==Belief vs. faith==
  
==Belief ''in'' something==
+
''[[Faith]]'' is sometimes defined as belief without evidence, or in the face of contradictory evidence. Clearly, "belief" does not always imply "faith," as one can believe something based on evidence or for other rational reasons (e.g., logical arguments). For example, one does not need to have faith that the [[sun]] will rise tomorrow, since the [[fact]] that the sun rises every day is supported by a lifetime of personal experience, thousands of years worth of recorded observations, and a scientific model of the earth's rotation on an axis.
  
Having '''''belief in''''' something is different from simply having a ''belief''.
+
===Belief in===
  
==Believers==
+
However, the definition of "faith" given above is usually not what religious people mean when they use the word: to them, having faith is closer to "trusting" than simply "believing" (see the [[Faith]] article for more information). The phrase "'''belief in'''" is sometimes used to imply this element of trust. For example, when [[Christian]]s say they "believe in" [[God]], they usually don't simply mean that they believe he exists, but that they believe he loves them, has a plan for their lives, will see them through hard times, etc. For this reason, when Christians ask what atheists "believe in", or whether an atheist "believes in" [[evolution]] or the [[big bang]], the best response is likely to include an explanation of the difference between belief and faith.
  
Calling someone a '''believer''' usually connotes belief in a god, especially the [[Christian]] God (in the U.S., anyway). Sometimes the belief is related to other claims, such as ESP or alien abduction.
+
==Philosophically==
 +
* How do we define belief and believing? If
 +
**A: Belief is a form of reason and reason denotes structure, then belief equals our awareness of the world through a structured combination of sensory input.
 +
***AA: Then the structure with the highest amount of order and inner coherence would be the most true. All closed logical speculations have a higher amount of truth then open and random speculations.
 +
****AB: If in theory no human mind can exist inside a closed logical mode, then all logical speculations must be inherently open, and open to random speculations. And the validity of these random speculations would only be laid down by the structured and organised mind mimicking a closed logical speculation system (dogma), then believe is always dogma and freedom is inclusion of all forms even if they contradict each other.
 +
**B: Belief is a lack of reason and would not denote structure but rather randomness projected on a structured consciousness.
 +
***BB: This would define all believe as raw sensory input and lead back to point A.
  
{{stub}}
+
{{Philosophy}}
  
 
[[Category:Epistemology]]
 
[[Category:Epistemology]]

Latest revision as of 02:35, 12 September 2011

Wikipedia-logo-en.png
For more information, see the Wikipedia article:
Wiktionary-logo-en.png
For more information, see the Wiktionary article:

Belief or believing, in simplest terms, is the acceptance by the mind of something as true. A belief is something which is believed. One can believe something to be true without having knowledge that it is true. Also, one can believe something to varying degrees of certainty (see also Probability).

Calling someone a believer often connotes belief in a god, especially the Christian God (in the U.S., anyway). There are many reasons people give for their belief in their god/s. Some amount to, “When I go outside and I look around I can only think god did it all.” Sometimes, though, the belief is related to some other supernatural or unsupported claim, such as ESP or alien abduction — or even to a philosophical position or political opinion.

Contents

Degrees of belief

Common phrases describing one's own degree of belief:

  • I know that
  • I believe that
  • I think that
  • I feel that
  • I [would] guess that
  • I [would] bet/wager that
  • I [would] like to think/believe that
  • I have no reason to doubt that
  • I have no reason not to believe/think that

Common phrases describing the degree of believability of a statement of fact:

  • It is true
  • It is certainly true
  • It is surely true
  • It is almost certainly/surely true
  • It is most likely true
  • It is likely true
  • It is probably true
  • It is possibly true
  • It is perhaps true
  • It may be true
  • It might be true
  • It should be true
  • It can/could be true

In addition, most of the above statements could be negated in two different ways, giving rise to different connotations. For example, "It is not likely true" is different from "It is likely not true".

Disbelief

The word disbelief has two possible connotations:

  1. lack of, or absence of, belief
  2. belief to the contrary

The two connotations are at the heart of the confusion between weak atheism (lack of belief in any gods) and strong atheism (positive belief that there are no gods).

See also Atheist vs. agnostic and Absolute certainty.

Belief vs. faith

Faith is sometimes defined as belief without evidence, or in the face of contradictory evidence. Clearly, "belief" does not always imply "faith," as one can believe something based on evidence or for other rational reasons (e.g., logical arguments). For example, one does not need to have faith that the sun will rise tomorrow, since the fact that the sun rises every day is supported by a lifetime of personal experience, thousands of years worth of recorded observations, and a scientific model of the earth's rotation on an axis.

Belief in

However, the definition of "faith" given above is usually not what religious people mean when they use the word: to them, having faith is closer to "trusting" than simply "believing" (see the Faith article for more information). The phrase "belief in" is sometimes used to imply this element of trust. For example, when Christians say they "believe in" God, they usually don't simply mean that they believe he exists, but that they believe he loves them, has a plan for their lives, will see them through hard times, etc. For this reason, when Christians ask what atheists "believe in", or whether an atheist "believes in" evolution or the big bang, the best response is likely to include an explanation of the difference between belief and faith.

Philosophically

  • How do we define belief and believing? If
    • A: Belief is a form of reason and reason denotes structure, then belief equals our awareness of the world through a structured combination of sensory input.
      • AA: Then the structure with the highest amount of order and inner coherence would be the most true. All closed logical speculations have a higher amount of truth then open and random speculations.
        • AB: If in theory no human mind can exist inside a closed logical mode, then all logical speculations must be inherently open, and open to random speculations. And the validity of these random speculations would only be laid down by the structured and organised mind mimicking a closed logical speculation system (dogma), then believe is always dogma and freedom is inclusion of all forms even if they contradict each other.
    • B: Belief is a lack of reason and would not denote structure but rather randomness projected on a structured consciousness.
      • BB: This would define all believe as raw sensory input and lead back to point A.


v · d Philosophy
History of philosophy   Ancient Greek philosophy · Rationalism · Post Modernism · Utilitarianism · Existentialism · Objectivism · Metaphysics of quality · Secular humanism · Transhumanism
Existence   Reality · Mind-body dualism · Purpose of existence · Value of life · Solipsism
Morality and ethics   Ethics of Aristotle · Relative morality · Objective morality · Golden rule
Epistemology   Belief · Truth · Justification · A priori · A posteriori · Observation · Analysis · Synthesis · Absolute certainty · Information theory · Plato's Apology of Socrates
Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox