Avoidance of hell

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Counter apologetics: Use singular links)
(Counter apologetics: I can't make myself beieve.)
Line 12: Line 12:
 
* Pascal's wager is an intellectual argument. The threat of hell is purely [[Appeal to emotion|emotional]].
 
* Pascal's wager is an intellectual argument. The threat of hell is purely [[Appeal to emotion|emotional]].
 
* With the threat of hell, hell is assumed to exist. Pascal's wager treats this as an unknown.
 
* With the threat of hell, hell is assumed to exist. Pascal's wager treats this as an unknown.
 +
 +
This argument has the same flaw as many others: even if one were convinced by it, how does one go about forcing oneself to believe in God?
  
 
[[Category:Arguments]]
 
[[Category:Arguments]]
 
[[Category:Criticisms of atheism]]
 
[[Category:Criticisms of atheism]]

Revision as of 15:19, 21 July 2007

"If you don't believe in God, you'll go to hell after you die."

The threat of hellfire is most effective against those who already believe in heaven and hell, such as theists who are angry with God. Its common use against nonbelievers is puzzling - because to threaten someone with something that they don't believe in is utterly ineffective.

Counter apologetics

The threat of eternal damnation and torment is an ever-popular argument of fundamentalists and presuppositionalists. It is simply an argumentum ad baculum, even though the person making the argument does not claim to be the one to carry it out.

An effective counter apologetic would be to ask for proof of hell, or to threaten them with another religion's hell, and point out the similarity. The threat of hell differs from Pascal's wager in several key respects:

  • Pascal's wager is an intellectual argument. The threat of hell is purely emotional.
  • With the threat of hell, hell is assumed to exist. Pascal's wager treats this as an unknown.

This argument has the same flaw as many others: even if one were convinced by it, how does one go about forcing oneself to believe in God?

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox