Argumentum ad populum

From Iron Chariots Wiki
Revision as of 23:47, 26 August 2006 by Arensb (Talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search

Argumentum ad populum (popular appeal, appeal to the majority) is a logical fallacy whereby a proposition is claimed to be true because it is believed by large numbers of people.

Examples

  • "Fifty million Elvis fans can't be wrong."
  • "All US presidents have been Christians. Maybe such a prestigious group of people is onto something."
  • "90% of the people in the world believe in God. Are you saying that all of them are wrong?"

Discussion

Argumentum ad populum comes in two varieties: the first is to argue from sheer numbers: "everyone knows X, so X must be true". This argument is appealing because in many cases, what "everyone knows" is true: the sun rises in the east, not the south; grass is green; and George Washington was the first president of the United States.

The second variety is snob appeal: a proposition is claimed to be true because it is believed by an elite or distinguished group of people. This argument often appears in advertising, e.g., "XYZ Cola: the official soft drink of the National Football League".

Counter-Apologetics

Argumentum ad populum is a fallacy because the fact that many people believe something does not make it true. For many years, most people believed that the Earth was the center and most important feature of the universe. Millions of people believe that astrology works. Neither is true.

One special case is that in which a statement is said to be true because it is believed by most of the experts in the field. For example, if most astronomers say that the Earth revolves around the sun instead of the other way around, then that is very likely to be true. In this case, however, we are trusting the judgment of people who have studied the matter. In effect, we are trusting that the experts have reached their conclusions through valid arguments, so there is no need for us to research the matter ourselves.

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox