Argument from justice

In his essay Why I Am Not a Christian, Bertrand Russell says:

Then there is another very curious form of moral argument, which is this: they say that the existence of God is required in order to bring justice into the world. In the part of this universe that we know there is great injustice, and often the good suffer, and often the wicked prosper, and one hardly knows which of those is the more annoying; but if you are going to have justice in the universe as a whole you have to suppose a future life to redress the balance of life here on earth. So they say that there must be a God, and there must be Heaven and Hell in order that in the long run there may be justice. That is a very curious argument. If you looked at the matter from a scientific point of view, you would say, "After all, I only know this world. I do not know about the rest of the universe, but so far as one can argue at all on probabilities one would say that probably this world is a fair sample, and if there is injustice here the odds are that there is injustice elsewhere also." Supposing you got a crate of oranges that you opened, and you found all the top layer of oranges bad, you would not argue, "The underneath ones must be good, so as to redress the balance." You would say, "Probably the whole lot is a bad consignment"; and that is really what a scientific person would argue about the universe. He would say, "Here we find in this world a great deal of injustice, and so far as that goes that is a reason for supposing that justice does not rule in the world; and therefore so far as it goes it affords a moral argument against deity and not in favor of one." Of course I know that the sort of intellectual arguments that I have been talking to you about are not what really moves people. What really moves people to believe in God is not any intellectual argument at all. Most people believe in God because they have been taught from early infancy to do it, and that is the main reason.

Then I think that the next most powerful reason is the wish for safety, a sort of feeling that there is a big brother who will look after you. That plays a very profound part in influencing people's desire for a belief in God.

v · d Arguments for the existence of god Anthropic arguments   Anthropic principle · Natural-law argument Arguments for belief   Pascal's Wager · Argument from faith · Just hit your knees Christological arguments   Christological argument · Argument from biblical miracles · Would someone die for a lie? · Liar, Lunatic or Lord Cosmological arguments   Cosmological argument · Fine-tuning argument · First cause argument · Kalam · Uncaused cause · Unmoved mover Majority arguments   Argumentum ad populum · Argument from admired religious scientists Moral arguments   Moral argument · Argument from justice · Divine command theory Ontological argument   Ontological argument · Argument from degree · Argument from goodness · Argument from desire Reformed epistemology   Argument from divine sense · Sensus divinitatis Teleological arguments   Argument from design · Banana argument · 747 Junkyard argument · Laminin argument Testimonial arguments   Personal revelation · Argument from observed miracles · Argument from personal experience · Consciousness argument for the existence of God · Emotional pleas Transcendental arguments   Transcendental argument · God created numbers Biblical arguments   Biblical knowledge of round earth before science