Apes, Lies and Ms. Henn (Chick tract)

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
 
Line 4: Line 4:
  
 
Panel 1
 
Panel 1
 +
 
Head Teacher: I have good news children. Your teacher, Mrs. Tucker, had twins! And here is your '''''new''''' teacher, Mrs. Henn.
 
Head Teacher: I have good news children. Your teacher, Mrs. Tucker, had twins! And here is your '''''new''''' teacher, Mrs. Henn.
 +
 
L'il Suzy: '''''Wow!'''''
 
L'il Suzy: '''''Wow!'''''
 +
 
Class: Good Morning, Mrs. Henn!
 
Class: Good Morning, Mrs. Henn!
 +
 
Mrs. Henn: Thank you, children.
 
Mrs. Henn: Thank you, children.
  
 
Panel 2
 
Panel 2
 +
 
Mrs Henn: We're going to be great friends...and you'll meet many of my close friends, too. We're going to have such fun together...as long as you do what I say!
 
Mrs Henn: We're going to be great friends...and you'll meet many of my close friends, too. We're going to have such fun together...as long as you do what I say!
  
Line 15: Line 20:
  
 
Panel 3
 
Panel 3
 +
 
LATER
 
LATER
 +
 
Mrs. Henn: Today I want you to know how great you are and how far humans have come. Soon we'll live in outer space. But it took millions of years to change from apes into humans.
 
Mrs. Henn: Today I want you to know how great you are and how far humans have come. Soon we'll live in outer space. But it took millions of years to change from apes into humans.
  
Line 21: Line 28:
  
 
Panel 4
 
Panel 4
 +
 
Kid: Did we really come from monkeys?
 
Kid: Did we really come from monkeys?
 +
 
Mrs. Henn: Yes, scientists have PROVEN it.
 
Mrs. Henn: Yes, scientists have PROVEN it.
 +
 
L'il Suzy: Timmy, that's a lie!
 
L'il Suzy: Timmy, that's a lie!
 +
 
Mrs. Henn: WHAT DID YOU JUST SAY!?
 
Mrs. Henn: WHAT DID YOU JUST SAY!?
  
 
{{Comment-box1|label=Comment:|text=The teacher is behaving as a straw man in this panel. A teacher would not get angry at the suggestion of creationism, in reality she would attept to correct the child's misconceptions.}}
 
{{Comment-box1|label=Comment:|text=The teacher is behaving as a straw man in this panel. A teacher would not get angry at the suggestion of creationism, in reality she would attept to correct the child's misconceptions.}}

Revision as of 15:42, 4 September 2007

Apes, Lies and Mrs Henn is a tract written by the evangelist Jack Chick. It contains a message for children about the supposed falsity of evolution.

Synopsis

Panel 1

Head Teacher: I have good news children. Your teacher, Mrs. Tucker, had twins! And here is your new teacher, Mrs. Henn.

L'il Suzy: Wow!

Class: Good Morning, Mrs. Henn!

Mrs. Henn: Thank you, children.

Panel 2

Mrs Henn: We're going to be great friends...and you'll meet many of my close friends, too. We're going to have such fun together...as long as you do what I say!

Comment: "You'll meet many of my close friends"? Usually, teachers don't invite their friends to class. And Chick is also portraying the teacher as visually unappealing, in order to get his message across.

Panel 3

LATER

Mrs. Henn: Today I want you to know how great you are and how far humans have come. Soon we'll live in outer space. But it took millions of years to change from apes into humans.

Comment: the species did not change from ape to human. Apoes and humans have a relatively recent common ancestor. Evolution is best not thought of as linear, but a better metaphor is a branching tree.

Panel 4

Kid: Did we really come from monkeys?

Mrs. Henn: Yes, scientists have PROVEN it.

L'il Suzy: Timmy, that's a lie!

Mrs. Henn: WHAT DID YOU JUST SAY!?

Comment: The teacher is behaving as a straw man in this panel. A teacher would not get angry at the suggestion of creationism, in reality she would attept to correct the child's misconceptions.

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
wiki navigation
IronChariots.Org
Toolbox